The revised NPLs data templates are overly detailed and impose more costs than benefits to banks and investors.They should not be mandatory, at least not for banks with low levels of NPLs.
BRUSSELS, 3 September 2021 – The European Savings and Retail Banking Group (ESBG) replied to the European Banking Authority (EBA) consultation on the review of the standardised data templates for Non-Performing Loans (NPLs) on 31 August.
The current revision of the templates is based on the user experience and feedback from various market participants. The revision responds to the European Commission’s Communication on tackling NPLs in the aftermath of the Covid-19 pandemic (December 2020) that, amongst others, requests the EBA to review the templates based on a consultation with market participants. The objective of this revision is to make the voluntary data templates simpler, more proportional and effective. It also aims to make them available to all market participants by the end of 2021. According to the authorities, this should play an important role in providing a common basis for data exchange in secondary markets.
From ESBG’s perspective, the data templates are overly detailed and require information that either is not critical for purposes of loan valuations or is not currently or readily available. Some data fields go beyond what is relevant for portfolio valuation.
Furthermore, the potential mandatory implementation of NPL data templates does not consider the role of all market participants and thus may have a negative impact on some of them.
The proposal to require that the preparation of these templates shall be mandatory for low NPL banks (NPL ratio lower than 5%) is detrimental, in ESBG’s view. It would be neither necessary (low NPL banks have no or little need to sell NPLs) nor would it make economic sense (the costs will surpass the benefits), nor would it materially support the build-up of a NPL trading market (as low NPL banks would not contribute to it). Such measure would also go against any proportionality considerations.
Content wise, the templates have also several downsides. Despite a significant decrease of the data fields compared to the original 2017 templates, the remaining number is still high, and contains significantly more information than the current market standard. An additional difficulty is related to the availability of information and to the existing barriers imposed by confidentiality rules. All these, if made obligatory, will put additional pressure that would outweigh benefits from the bank´s perspective due to the need for increased engagement of resources.
In addition, it is also worth considering whether the revised templates (which are still too detailed and granular) would actually make it more time consuming for investors, particularly those new to the market, to conduct the valuation process, and whether this might have a detrimental rather than stimulating impact on the NPLs market.
In light of the above, ESBG firmly believes that banks (or at least low level NPL banks) should be given a discretion to decide on the use of the NPL data templates even in this revised format, rather than being obliged. ESBG members have in fact the required levels of operational readiness to deal with the increase in NPLs, when (and if) the need emerges.
In conclusion, while we understand the rationality of aiming to increase the market transparency by making available the NPL secondary market data, we recommend that the implementation solution should be done without bringing any additional complexity, investments and effort for all players, and using existing regulatory and legal framework and IT infrastructure. If the initiative will be continued, we propose to use the already existing Credit Bureaus EU infrastructure, at least for the retail segment, as an alternative solution which may fulfil the original objective and does not require new reporting requirements for the banks.
Download
related
May 17, 2022
Data Act – An open data economy should be multilateral and cross-sectoral
ESBG's response to the European Commission consultation on the proposed Data Act calls for a horizontal regulatory approach to establish a consistent and harmonised rules for all sectors. ESBG is the…
May 12, 2022
Overtime for Ukrainian war refugees: DSGV employees donate over 100,000 euros through extra work
European Savings and Retail Banking Group members are standing in solidarity with people in need in Ukraine.
May 12, 2022
Stand with Ukraine: Erste family provides extensive humanitarian aid
European Savings and Retail Banking Group members are standing in solidarity with people in need in Ukraine.
May 12, 2022
The German Savings Banks Association ( DSVG ): More than 100,000 accounts already opened for Ukrainian war refugees
European Savings and Retail Banking Group members are standing in solidarity with people in need in Ukraine.
May 12, 2022
CaixaBank has been leveraging its network of branches in Spain to assist asylum seekers and refugees fleeing Ukraine
European Savings and Retail Banking Group members are standing in solidarity with people in need in Ukraine.
May 12, 2022
Ukraine: ESBG members reaffirm their social responsibility
European Savings and Retail Banking Group members are standing in solidarity with people in need in Ukraine.
April 28, 2022
ESBG response to ESMA’s consultation on guidelines of MiFID II suitability requirements
ESBG's response to the European Securities and Market Authority (ESMA) consultation on some MiFID II sustainability aspects. European banks calls for clear procedures and to avoid unnecessary…
April 4, 2022
Developing a proportionate, fair and efficient IRRBB framework in the EU
On 4 April 2022, ESBG responded to the EBA consultation specifying technical aspects of the revised framework capturing interest rate risks for banking book (IRRBB) positions.
March 24, 2022
ESBG members waive bank transfer costs to support Ukrainian people
European Savings and Retail Banking Group members are standing in solidarity with people in need in Ukraine.
March 7, 2022
European Commission review of the Mortgage Credit Directive
SBG sent its response to the European Commission questionnaire on what to include in the upcoming Review of the Mortgage Credit Directive (MCD).